I would say you need a new ps. The 12V is what powers most items in a modern system. Even though your ps has 50A on the 5V rail, it is woefully underpowered on the 12V rail.
This would be about the min ps I would install in something like that system. It is a 400W unit, however it has dual 12V rails with a combined amp of 36 amps on both rails.
Sparkle power supply
This would be about the min ps I would install in something like that system. It is a 400W unit, however it has dual 12V rails with a combined amp of 36 amps on both rails.
Sparkle power supply